Formless vs James vs Lily (Spoiler Warning!!!)

There are three endings in this part of the game: Formless, James, and Lily. Each results from choices made in key scenes in chapters 1-4. The ending depends on how many times the player chooses to comply with the Director:

• Ch1: checkpoint CH1_Decision

Obedience: Shooting the female mannequin on the right

Disobedience: Shooting the male mannequin on the left

• Ch2: checkpoint CH2_Decision

Obedience: Taking the meat from the dog 

Disobedience: Not taking the meat from the dog

• Ch3: checkpoint CH3_Decision

Obedience: Shooting the puppets on the left and right side

Disobedience: Shooting the girl in the middle 

• Ch4: checkpoint CH4_Decision

Obedience: In the flooded corridor, the player has to turn back and go with the flow into the fire

Disobedience: In the flooded corridor, the player has to go against the flow till the end of the corridor 

If the player is obedient 3 or 4 times = James Ending

If the player is obedient 2 times = Formless Ending

If the player is obedient 1 or 0 times = Lily Ending